James and Jimmy crush it weekly and more...get into this!

I’m not a huge fan of Ice Cream, but I’ll say I do because you told me to and because this show is hilarious and great!

Disclaimer!!

Nothing compares! I look forward to every new episode! These guys are the best!

I listen to podcasts from these guys while I work and they make me laugh all day. I can’t wait till the next episode!!

Obsess obsess!!! Love it !!!

Fun show!

This podcast and your stupid opinions are hilarious

Can you do the Nathan Brooks murders in Bellaire, Ohio please?

Fantastically funny true crime. These guys never fail to make me laugh out loud. Highly recommend

Great podcast. Perfect for listening to while walking or driving somewhere,

I feel like I’m hanging out with 2 friends who have the same sense of humor as I do. Kind of nice to know, there’s at least 2 other people out there that are just as f’d as me.

I love all these new cases! I already know them but 2 hours of well researched info hits different. Well done

I’m currently binging your show. I can’t listen to anything else. I love the comedy. The banter is hilarious. I purchased the Halloween live show, the costumes were awesome! I was super stoked to find that the case you covered was here in Oregon. Keep doing what you’re doing. Shut up and give me murder💀🔪

I am late to the party but love this podcast.

No. Don’t listen. Disgusting.

I have binged all your episodes, but needed more, so I joined patreon!!!! Looking forward to getting to hear a lot more!!! Y’all keep up the good work! From Happier Than Ever in Georgia!

This podcast is my favorite of all time. It has made the other podcasts I used to listen to annoying now. I am not looking forward to the day I finish all the episodes.

Hilarious spin on telling frightening, crazy tales of murder. My go to listen every week! Love these guys and all the work they put into this!

Need I say more? No, I shouldn’t, and neither should anyone else. Instead, they should SHUT UP AND GIVE ME MURDER!

Tried spray cheese because of the podcast and they were right . It’s amazing(gave me diarrhea but still good )

New to the podcast and am absolutely obsessed! It will def make you cry laughing!

Really, I enjoy this podcast so much. I love that they really do an in depth review of everything about the case. Such a great podcast!

Love the show but lately James is a little rough on Jimmie…And can you guys edit out the phlemmy hacking?

Love you guys. Just missed you in OKC! Thank you for what you do!

The best podcast out there! You guys are great! Keep it up! 🦃

It’s ok. When I read the reviews about it being so funny, I guess I was expecting something like The Dollop but for murders. It’s not that. It’s just another murder show but the stories presented in a lighter tone. I’m sure it’s great for people who want to like true crime but don’t like the inevitable darkness and depravity that go along with it. This show is far from funny though.

STM has ruined every other true crime podcast I used to listen to.

These guys are hilarious! I listen to this show and their other show, “Your Stupid Opinions” every week!

Frozen fluffernutters rock! Grilled cheese sandwiches made in a waffle iron are great with soups!!!

Gobble gobble

I love this show and every one they do, best laughs and crazy stories. Any road trip or time driving they’re on.

Haven’t turned my radio on in my car in 3 years because of these hooligans! 😁

I am absolutely obsessed I started at the beginning and have got 127 episodes in so far, but I hope nothing changes but for the good! You two are hilarious and save the day while I work or I wouldn’t it make it through the day!!

I love these guys they make me laugh every time

I like Italian sandwiches

Definitely my favorite podcast

Listened to all the episodes and love the show!

Shut up and Give me Murder!!!! Amazing show! Discovered it about 2 months ago and im on episode 106 so still alot of catching up to do !

I have listened to all the episodes. Love how I can be horrified one second and then laughing the next.

because it’s funniest podcast ever!!

Love these Jimmie/James!!!!!

This podcast isn’t for the feint of heart by any means. I hear things I never would have dreamed of and I love every minute of it. If you don’t mind a potty mouth and love outrageous true stories, then this is for you!

By far my favorite podcast! I can’t get enough.

I found this podcast a few weeks ago and have been binge listening ever since. These guys are the best!

Really good research and super funny!

Thankful for the laughs this show gives me.

Shut up and listen already

Zero, just a zero. Too rehearsed. Trying too hard to make all the rehearsing “funny”. This is podcasting. Lose the radio/NPR voice work. It’s inauthentic & annoying. If you have to try THIS hard, and still cannot put out a good Pod…maybe find another avenue.

Best pod cast ever! Love these two guys, the way they tell a story, and the humor thrown in to make listening to some gruesome murder just a little more entertaining!